As Shane has entered his 21st year of wrongful incarceration, I think these words from our investigator Doug Walters serve as a powerful reminder of what this case is all about. Doug wrote these words as part of his superb summary of the case back in 2012:
My conclusions about the case of Shane Watson are that this case represents
a complete and deliberate miscarriage of justice. This is not a case of a
witness misleading the authorities, but of the authorities willingly suborning a witness. The actions, and
inaction of the NYPD and the Bronx District Attorney in this case go far beyond
negligence, and constitute actual malfeasance. The NYPD and Bronx District
Attorney showed an obvious contempt for Shane Watson and his family by
fabricating a case against him in order to lock him up for life. They showed a
complete disregard for Mark Johnson and his family by treating his murder as
merely an occasion for obtaining a false conviction with a base minimum of
work. They showed a contempt for the professional standards which are supposed
to govern everyone in the criminal justice system. And they showed contempt for
the constitution they were sworn to uphold and the society they were supposed
to protect by disdaining to make the slightest effort to look for the person
who actually committed this brutal murder in the midst of a neighborhood
suffering the repeated trauma of senseless violence.
When the sordid and unjust dealings of the guardians of law and order in
this case become obvious to us, our response should be to “let justice roll
down like waters”, but the American criminal justice system is a calcified
institution, often consumed by an obsession with process and procedure to the
exclusion of weightier matters like justice and compassion. However obvious the
right thing to do might seem, we
still have a long and difficult road with many institutional obstacles to
overcome before any of the victims in the Shane Watson case can be made whole.
As a postscript, I am happy to say that my involvement in this case has been
a blessing and an inspiration to me, and what I take to be a revelation of
God’s grace in Shane Watson’s life. While imprisonment has certainly had a
corrupting and degrading effect on many lives, Shane Watson has truly been
turned into another man. He has an unblemished disciplinary record in prison
and has been on the “honor block” at Green Haven for many years. He got his
G.E.D. in prison (by the wisdom of politicians, college programs in New York
State prisons were discontinued many years ago) and has worked in the
upholstery shop with an excellent record. He was baptized in 1996 and attends church
services regularly. He is a faithful student with a better knowledge of the
Bible than almost anyone I have ever met outside of an academic setting. Shane
is devoted to his wife Paula and to his two small children, Diana and Zion. In
the midst of terrible circumstances I have never heard him utter a word of
bitterness against anyone, and he leads a life of quiet witness to his faith.
Truly can Shane Watson say to his persecutors, as Joseph said to his brothers,
“As for you, you meant it against me for evil, but God meant it for good.”
My phone rang at 5:51 PM. The caller ID read "Garden City, NY". It was Amy, Robert Moore's girlfriend, who asked if I'...
Several months ago I wrote to Bronx District Attorney Darcel D. Clark, asking that she take a look at Shane's case in light of the new ...
A recent editorial in the Connecticut Post (We must defuse the rage", July 10, 2016) was well-meaning but heavy on platitudes and shor...
The Bronx has a new District Attorney. Her name is Darcel D. Clark. According to our friend Alice Wagner of NYC, "i t looks like the ...